
Calibrating Western Philosophy for India: Rousseau, Derrida, Deleuze, Guattari, Bergson, and Vaddera Chandidas by A. Raghuramaraju, published in 2019 by Routledge India, is a groundbreaking work in comparative philosophy that proposes a novel methodology for engaging with Western philosophical ideas in the Indian context. Raghuramaraju, a professor at the Indian Institute of Technology Tirupati, challenges the colonial practice of uncritically importing Western philosophical frameworks, which he argues often prove incongruent, irrelevant, or unproductive when applied directly to Indiaâs diverse and complex social, cultural, and historical realities. Instead, he advocates a process of âbending and reassemblingâ the ideas of Western philosophersâJean-Jacques Rousseau, Jacques Derrida, Gilles Deleuze, FĂ©lix Guattari, and Henri Bergsonâto make them resonate with Indian thought and society. The book also introduces the philosophy of Vaddera Chandidas, a neglected modern Indian thinker, whose concepts of non-being and negation are presented as an innovative extension of Western ideas, offering a distinctly Indian contribution to global philosophy.
Raghuramaraju begins by critiquing the colonial methodology that assumes Western philosophyâs universal applicability, often ignoring local contexts. He argues that this approach fails to address Indiaâs unique philosophical traditions and contemporary challenges, such as its blend of pre-modern and modern elements. For instance, he reinterprets Rousseauâs ideas of freedom and the social contract, bending them to address Indiaâs communal and hierarchical social structures, contrasting them with Gandhiâs notions of non-violence and self-rule. Similarly, Derridaâs deconstruction is reassembled to engage with Indian linguistic and cultural diversity, moving beyond its Western logocentric critique to explore non-Western discourses like those in the Upanishads. Deleuze and Guattariâs concepts of rhizomatic structures and minor literature are recalibrated to reflect Indiaâs pluralistic social fabric, with Raghuramaraju highlighting their relevance to marginalized voices in Indian society. Bergsonâs notions of duration and intuition are adapted to align with Indian metaphysical traditions, such as Advaita Vedanta, to explore temporality and consciousness in a non-Western framework.
A significant portion of the book is dedicated to Vaddera Chandidas, whose 1975 work Desire and Liberation: The Fundamentals of Cosmicontology (republished in 2018 with Raghuramarajuâs introduction) offers a radical rethinking of existence through the politics of non-being and negation. Raghuramaraju positions Chandidas as a bridge between Western and Indian philosophy, arguing that his ideas extend beyond Bergsonâs and Deleuzeâs frameworks by grounding them in Indian metaphysical concerns, such as those found in the Vedas and Upanishads. For example, Chandidasâs exploration of non-being resonates with Indian philosophical traditions that prioritize transcendence and liberation, offering a critique of Western ontologyâs focus on permanence and presence. This comparative approach not only enriches the dialogue between philosophical traditions but also challenges the Eurocentrism of global philosophical discourse.
The book is structured to guide readers through this recalibration process, with chapters addressing each Western philosopherâs ideas, their limitations in the Indian context, and their reassembly alongside Chandidasâs contributions. Raghuramaraju draws on a wide range of references, from classical Indian texts like the ChÄndogya Upanishad to modern Indian thinkers like Gandhi and Bhattacharyya, to illustrate how Western philosophy can be made relevant through creative adaptation. His methodology, inspired by Deleuzeâs notion of âassemblageâ and Whiteheadâs idea of philosophical coupling, emphasizes dialogue and transformation over rigid application, advocating for a cross-cultural philosophy that respects local frameworks.
Calibrating Western Philosophy for India is a significant intervention in philosophical methodology, appealing to scholars of Indian philosophy, Western philosophy, comparative studies, postcolonial studies, and political philosophy. It has been praised for its innovative approach and rigorous scholarship, earning a 5.0/5 rating from limited Amazon reviews. However, its dense academic style may challenge general readers. Available in hardcover, paperback, and eBook formats, the book underscores Raghuramarajuâs broader project of fostering dialogue between Indian and Western thought, as seen in his other works like Debates in Indian Philosophy (2006) and Philosophy and India (2013). By centering Chandidas and reinterpreting Western thinkers, Raghuramaraju offers a compelling vision for a decolonized, context-sensitive philosophy that bridges global and local perspectives